Best Cookie Exchange Recipes Everyone Will Love

Who doesn't love a delicious Christmas colored cookie? These M&M holiday treats are sure to be a hit at any cookie exchange!

These cookies are a great twist on the sugar cookie classic. They’re made with eggnog instead of milk and come out so delicious! You can even try using flavored eggnog for an even tastier result!

This sinfully delicious, easy to make peanut butter fudge will have everyone asking for more. Perfect for holiday cookie exchanges or gifts for your co-workers and neighbors. This is one recipe you will make over and over again!

These adorable peanut butter cookies will certainly impress your friends. Get the kids involved because everyone will enjoy giving and receiving these treats.

I made these a few years ago for the first time, and they have been a household favorite ever since. You may think you're not a gingerbread fan, but you will be after you try these.

These just scream Christmas, don’t they?! These are so much fun and a great option for cookie exchanges.

These are so festive and delicious! They’re chocolate cookies with melted marshmallows with a chocolate drizzle and some sprinkles. SO GOOD!!

These cookies are so good! The red velvet flavor against the delicious filling is pure heaven.

These easy to make coconut macaroons are sure to be a hit!

These adorable melted snowman cookies are easy to make! Kids will love helping with these fun creations.

As the recipe says, these are "the best" chocolate chip cookies, and we have to agree. They are the perfect thickness, soft, and gooey. Yum, we can't resist!

Truffles anyone? These delicious cookies utilize golden oreos that are then dipped in chocolate with sprinkles added on top. They’re so good without being too rich! You won’t be able to eat just one, that’s for certain.

These chocolate cookies are SO GOOD! They scream Christmas and are so easy to make.

Snickerdoodles are another classic you can’t possibly leave out! So good and so easy to bake.

Chocolate cookies with a peppermint candy pressed into the middle? YES PLEASE! These are so festive, flavorful, and perfect for a cookie exchange!

These cookies are so good you’ll have to make an extra batch to keep to yourself! Roll them up like mini cinnamon rolls, slice, bake, and add the glaze. They’re so delicious!

These are some of my favorite cookies. They’re like a Reese’s peanut butter cup - but better! They are sure to be a real crowd pleaser.

These are a true classic cookie option. So easy to make, fun to decorate, and delicious to eat. Try mixing up the sprinkles with a more festive option!

If I could eat these the entire holiday break, I certainly would. Far and away my all time favorite holiday treat (next to mom's peanut butter fudge of course), and super easy to make!

This Christmas classic is a must during the holidays. They’re buttery and nutty with an airy texture that will surely melt in your mouth

How DELICIOUS do these look?! A great update on a classic that everyone will love.

Pizzelles were a Christmas tradition at my grandmother's house (and she wasn't even Italian)! These light, crispy cookies are easy to make with a pizzelle maker, and you can make different flavors!

These are made with Rolos and so good! A chocolate cookie cup filled with a Rolo candy is nothing short of delicious.

These are much like the chocolate ones, but so much more festive! They’re made from cake mix, making them super easy to bake.

Honestly, these might not make it to the cookie exchange! Chocolate cookies held together by a cheesecake mixture is pure heaven. Yum!